Posted by Riikka under 'The Other Boleyn Girl' with 2 Comments

Under the cut you can find some advance test screening reviews of The Other Boleyn Girl, which was recently held in New York City. They’re very much mixed. Click here and here for full reviews as I’ve mainly included the bits related to Scarlett’s performance. Please do not read if you don’t want to be spoiled at all!

Thanks to thevoid99 for the heads-up!

Johansson, who I usually like, is cursed with playing a character that seems indifferent to everything. She may not be happy when she is told that she has to leave her husband to become mistress to the king, but she’s a trooper and goes along with it. She goes along with everything in this film, making her one of the most accommodating and bland characters I’ve seen in a while. Portman has the more interesting of the roles as the conniving, power hungry, dominant sister. Portman probably gives the strongest performance in the film, though she rarely makes you understand why Anne does the things she does, other than the fact that because this is history and this is how it happened… maybe. Neither girl is great with the British accent, though Portman holds on to hers more often than Johansson.

If I haven’t mentioned Ms. Johansson up until this point, its because she is the cast’s weakest link. This is a role she should’ve been able to do more with: yes, the character of Mary is suppose to pale in comparison to her sister, but Ms. Johansson doesn’t just pale–she disappears. The quiet fire she exhibited in Lost In Translation would have served her here–without any life behind her character’s tiredness, Mary appears to drift from scene to scene and the strength the character needs to find in the script’s crucial moments feels forced, like we are expected to believe something that isn’t there. It’s a disappointing turn that fans of the book will love (other audience members seemed to feel she got it just right), that casual filmgoers will not understand.

All these flaws aside, I really did enjoy myself. There’s a lot to admire here: the gorgeous costumes, the strong performances, some moments of undeniable power and emotional punch, particularly in the film’s third act, which goes from dark to pitch black with the flip of a switch and got my pulse pounding. I did care for these characters. I wished them better lives than their actions delivered them.

  • SunshineHanni
    Posted on October 11, 2007

    what a pity that scarlett gets such bad crttics. i also love natalie but i hoped that both will shine in this movie. actually i like the book, it kept me reading till the early morning. no matter what the review says, i’m gonna watch this movie definitely. it couldn’t be that terrible and both of my most beloved actresses are in the cast. can’t wait and i’m very excited.

  • Mycah
    Posted on October 11, 2007

    I agree, I hope Natalie and Scarlett will do well together either way. I still can’t wait to see it!

  • Leave a Reply

    Site Advertisement
    Current Projects
    Captain America: Civil War (2016)
    Scarlett Johansson as Natasha Romanoff / Black Widow
    Status: Out May 06th, 2016 (USA).
    An incident leads to the Avengers developing a schism over how to deal with situations, which escalates into an open fight between allies Iron Man and Captain America..

    Hail, Caesar! (2016)
    Scarlett Johansson as Unknown At This Time
    Status: post-production.
    A Hollywood fixer in the 1950s works to keep the studio's stars in line.

    The Jungle Book (2016)
    Scarlett Johansson as Kaa
    Status: post-production.
    An orphan boy is raised in the Jungle with the help of a pack of wolves, a bear and a black panther.

    Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015)
    Scarlett Johansson as Natasha Romanoff / Black Widow
    Status: Out On Blu-Ray October 02nd, 2015 (USA).
    When Tony Stark and Bruce Banner try to jump-start a dormant peacekeeping program called Ultron, things go horribly wrong and it's up to Earth's Mightiest Heroes to stop the villainous Ultron from enacting his terrible plans.
    Latest Phoots

    view the entire Photo Gallery with over 69,000 Scarlett photos and still growing!
    Avengers Assemble
    Elite & Top Affiliates

    Modeling Projects
    Dolce & Gabanna: 2009-2014
    Info | Photos | Official
    The Singles
    Scarlett's all new girl group called The Singles, First song is out now to pre-order called Candy

    Gif Of The Month

    Made By Unknown
    Photo Of The Month
    Scarlett Supports
    ... read more
    Site Information
    Webmistress: Abby
    Previous: Aniek, Camilla, Jess, Riikka, Lisa
    Contact: By email
    Design: Ten Thousand Beats
    Host: Flaunt
    Online Since: August 2001

    To view Scarlett-Fan at its prettiest, a screen resolution of at at least 1024x768 in the latest version of Firefox/Chrome is recommended.
    Flaunt - DMCA